Signing Vick a good or bad Idea? I think both. A good idea because Vick is a 8 year pro and McNabb is a 11 year Pro so as soon as McNabb Retires they will have Vick as there QB instead of having to draft one that you don't know will be good. Bad because McNabb feels the pressure that if he doesn't do good then he will be replaced. So then he will be so pressured about it that he will play bad.